The recovery of Canada’s housing market post-2024 faces a significant challenge—high levels of household debt. Even with recent rate cuts by the Bank of Canada, which brought the overnight rate down to 3.75% following four consecutive reductions, high debt burdens continue to weigh on Canadian households. This scenario complicates the potential for a swift recovery in the real estate sector, as many buyers remain cautious about new mortgage commitments despite more favorable interest rates.
Canada’s Household Debt Crisis
Canadian households are among the most indebted in the world, with the household debt-to-income ratio exceeding 180% in 2024. This means that for every dollar of disposable income, Canadians owe $1.80 in debt. Most of this debt is tied to mortgages, a figure that has grown dramatically since the housing boom in the 2010s when ultra-low interest rates led to a borrowing frenzy.
According to Statistics Canada, mortgage debt rose by 6.4% year-over-year in 2024, reaching nearly $2.1 trillion. A significant portion of this debt is held by variable-rate borrowers who experienced sharp increases in monthly payments when interest rates peaked at 5% in 2023. Although the recent rate cuts have provided some relief, the accumulated debt remains a considerable obstacle.
The Impact of High Household Debt on Real Estate Demand
1. Constrained Buyer Power
Even with falling interest rates, potential homebuyers face difficulty qualifying for new mortgages due to high debt levels. Many households have already stretched their borrowing capacity to the maximum, leaving little room for further leveraging, even as borrowing costs become more affordable.
Data from the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC) shows that first-time homebuyers, a critical segment of the real estate market, are most affected by the debt burden. The CMHC reported that in Q3 2024, mortgage applications by first-time buyers dropped by 8.2%, reflecting the hesitancy in entering the housing market despite improved borrowing conditions.
2. Dampened Market Activity
With household debt so high, the overall housing market remains subdued, even as mortgage rates fall. The Bank of Canada’s October 2024 Monetary Policy Report highlights that while home prices in key markets like Toronto and Vancouver have stabilized, high debt levels are slowing down transaction volumes. Nationally, housing transactions are still 13% below their pre-pandemic levels, underscoring how high household indebtedness curtails market activity.
In cities like Vancouver, where average home prices exceeded $1.2 million in 2024, many prospective buyers are locked out of the market due to high monthly payments and stringent mortgage stress tests. A stress test introduced in 2018, which requires buyers to qualify at a higher rate than their contract mortgage rate, remains a significant hurdle despite recent policy adjustments.
Mortgage Delinquencies and Defaults
While defaults on mortgages remain relatively low at 0.19% in Q3 2024, there are growing signs of stress in the system. Equifax Canada noted a 12% rise in mortgage delinquencies among borrowers with variable-rate mortgages over the past year. This uptick in delinquencies reflects the financial strain that many homeowners faced during the period of high interest rates in 2023. As rates decline, the impact will ease, but the hangover from prior rate hikes means that many Canadians are still struggling to keep up with their debt obligations.
The Bank of Canada also cautioned in its October 2024 Financial Stability Report that households with high debt loads are particularly vulnerable to financial shocks. This vulnerability is exacerbated by slowing wage growth and rising inflation, which leave less disposable income to service mortgages.
The Taxation Impact on Real Estate Speculation
Another complicating factor is the federal government’s decision to tax real estate flips as business income rather than capital gains, introduced in 2023. This tax, while aimed at curbing speculative activity, has not led to a significant reduction in housing demand from investors. In Q3 2024, 2.4% of homes sold in Canada were flipped within 12 months, a figure just 0.2 percentage points below the all-time high. Investor interest remains strong, particularly in regions where population growth and rental demand continue to outpace housing supply, such as Calgary and Ottawa.
Implications for the Housing Market Recovery
1. Gradual Recovery, Not a Boom
Although interest rate cuts to 3.75% should theoretically boost demand, the high level of household debt will likely result in a slow and measured recovery rather than a rapid surge in homebuying activity. Potential buyers are still recovering from the financial strain of the past two years and are cautious about taking on new debt.
A study by RBC Economics in October 2024 indicated that the housing market will likely see a 3% rise in home sales in 2025, but this will be well below the 10-15% annual growth rates seen during the pre-pandemic years. The recovery is expected to be uneven across regions, with Ontario and British Columbia lagging behind provinces like Alberta and Nova Scotia, where housing affordability remains more reasonable.
2. Limited Price Appreciation
Home prices are expected to remain relatively stable in 2025, with the Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA) predicting national average price growth of 1-2%. In high-debt regions like Greater Toronto Area (GTA) and Metro Vancouver, price increases will likely be muted due to affordability constraints, despite a growing population and demand for housing. This contrasts sharply with markets like Calgary, where lower home prices relative to wages have kept housing demand stronger.
Conclusion
The Canadian housing market's post-2024 recovery will be shaped by the interplay between high household debt and easing monetary policy. While falling interest rates provide some relief to borrowers, the heavy debt burden carried by Canadian households limits the potential for a robust housing market resurgence. With household debt levels at record highs and delinquencies beginning to rise, the recovery will be slow and regionally varied. For real estate professionals, understanding the dynamics of debt and its impact on housing demand will be crucial as Canada navigates this complex economic landscape.
Sources:
The content of this article is for informational purposes only and should not be considered as financial, legal, or professional advice. Coldwell Banker Horizon Realty makes no representations as to the accuracy, completeness, or suitability of the information provided. Readers are encouraged to consult with qualified professionals regarding their specific real estate, financial, and legal circumstances. The views expressed in this article may not necessarily reflect the views of Coldwell Banker Horizon Realty or its agents. Real estate market conditions and government policies may change, and readers should verify the latest updates with appropriate professionals.
